Why is Jupiter’s Great Red Spot … Red?

Scientists think they've figured out what causes the mysterious ruddy coloring in the giant planet's enormous oval storm.

Jupiter's appearance in February 2014

Earlier this year, the Great Red Spot stood out prominently against Jupiter's bright zones and dark belts.
Damian Peach

When it comes to well-known planetary features, Jupiter's iconic Great Red Spot is near the top of everyone's list. It's truly enormous — much bigger than Earth — though its girth has shrunk over the past decade.

The Great Red Spot is as mysterious as it is majestic. Unlike hurricanes and cyclones on Earth, which come and go in a matter of days, this iconic oval has endured for centuries. Giovanni Battista Riccioli and Gian Domenico Cassini noted it during the mid-1600s, though it could well have existed well before then.

Astronomers have long pondered what causes the GRS to be so red — at least most of the time (the intensity of its hue changes, varying from a dark salmon to nearly white).

One important clue comes from the spot's overall structure and 5-day-long rotation. Unlike terrestrial hurricanes, which are low-pressure storms, the GRS is a high-pressure (anticyclonic) system that's much taller than the clouds surrounding it. The spot's cloudy interior is also relatively opaque, meaning whatever particles are coloring it must float near the top of this giant, buoyant bubble.

Cassini's infrared view of Jupiter

The Great Red Spot's appearance at three infrared wavelengths, as recorded by NASA's Galileo spacecraft in 1996, provides important clues to the big storm's characteristics.
NASA / JPL / K. Baines

For decades atmospheric chemists believed that the spot was tinted with phosphine (PH3), an unusual compound found in the Jovian atmosphere. But more recently attention has focused on sulfur and its colorful allotropes. One of Jupiter's three dense cloud layers consists of ammonium hydrosulfide (NH4SH), which, the thinking goes, could be dredged up by atmospheric convection and broken down by sunlight to form elemental sulfur.

That's what Kevin Baines, Robert Carlson, and Thomas Momary (all at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory) had in mind when they began laboratory experiments to try to replicate the coloring process. Carlson irradiated ammonium hydrosulfide with ultraviolet light, to mimic sunlight. But the resulting compounds were bright green, not red!

So the researchers instead tried irradiating a mixture of ammonia (NH3) and acetylene (C2H2), both of which exist in Jupiter's upper atmosphere. The result was a red concoction of cyanide-like molecules with the general formula HxCyNz where x, y, and z vary. Better still, the reddish particles have a spectrum that closely matches what NASA's Cassini spacecraft recorded inside the Great Red Spot when it swept by Jupiter in late 2000 while en route to Saturn.

Baines, Carlson, and Momary find that the best match involves particles just 400 nanometers across (the wavelength of blue light) thinly scattered in a layer only a few kilometers thick. The stuff looks red because it absorbs blue light strongly. "The model that fits is basically a 'crème brûlée' or 'strawberry-frosted cake' model," Baines explains, with a narrow layer of reddish material on top of the main, whitish cloud layer. So beneath its reddish veneer, created at a pressure level of roughly 300 millibars, the Great Red Spot would actually look rather bland.

Cassini's view of Great Red Spot

NASA's Cassini spacecraft captured the complex circulation inside the Great Red Spot when it swept past Jupiter (en route to Saturn) on December 29, 2000.
NASA / JPL / Space Science Inst.

The spot's rotation isolates and confines the atmospheric gases inside it, allowing these reddish colorants (impress your friends: they're technically called chromophores) to accumulate. "The GRS acts as a cauldron," Baines explains, "confining materials and letting them cook."

So why does the GRS's color vary so much over time? Apparently its hue depends on how much of ammonia and acetylene are present, their exact altitude, and how long they're exposed to sunlight. But the chemical conversion is rapid — Baines says they able to create the basic colors after just one day of "tanning" of the gas mixture in their lab tests.

The three researchers presented their findings Friday at the annual meeting of the American Astronomical Society's Division for Planetary Sciences. A full account has been submitted to Icarus, but you can also find details in this JPL press release.

Track down Jupiter and a host of other celestial sights with SkyWatch, our annual observing guide. Choose from the 2014 edition or the 2015 edition.

2 thoughts on “Why is Jupiter’s Great Red Spot … Red?

  1. Robert-Ashcraft

    My first view of the Red Spot was with a 40 mm refactor at 25X in late December of 1953. At that time the spot was really red, not the pale, washed-out salmon color it is today.

  2. KevinKevin

    I wasn’t aware that the GRS cloud structure rose above the surrounding cloud tops. It would be nice to have a more definitive measurement than “much higher.” Is it 10 miles, 200 miles or just a few miles? I’ll do some research and find out.

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.