7 Decades of Sky & Telescope - Now Available!


Alan MacRobert
HIGHLIGHTS by Alan MacRobert

The August Mars Hoax Is Back

Mars Hoax screen shot
NO WAY. This is a screen shot from a version of the August Mars chain letter we've received, pictures and all. Some versions of the letter mention that the Mars view has to be magnified 75 times to look like this, but even that hasn't been true since August 2003. For the real comparison, see below.
S&T: Alan MacRobert
It's almost August, and you know what that means. The August Mars Hoax is starting to go around again.

I just got a call from an astronomy educator in Louisiana. A TV station in Shreveport called him to check the news they'd heard that Mars will soon come so close to Earth that it will appear as big and bright as the Moon.

Actually, "hoax" is the wrong word for this thing, unless some joker is now spreading it knowingly (quite possible). It's an e-mail chain letter claiming that Mars will come closer than ever in history on August 23rd and will look as big as the full Moon. If your well-meaning great-aunt or your cousin's brother-in-law's dog hasn't sent it to you, it's probably just a matter of time.

What's going on is this. Back on August 23, 2003 (that's 2003 with a 3, folks), Mars had an especially favorable opposition, coming close enough to appear 25 arcseconds wide. That's still pretty tiny even in a telescope — smaller, for instance, than Jupiter always appears.

Moon and Mars
THE REAL STORY. Even when Mars is closest and brightest at opposition, it looks like an orangish star, nowhere near as big and bright as the full Moon.
S&T: Rick Fienberg
Back then, someone somewhere pointed out that at a magnification of 75× in a telescope, Mars would appear as big in the eyepiece (½° wide) as the Moon does unmagnified. True enough. But two things happened, as often do with chain letters. First, it got rewritten bit by bit to improve the story as people passed it around, so that the "75× in a telescope" was downplayed or, in some versions, left out. Second, the chain letter kept going and going, with the same breathless excitement, long after August 2003 receded into the mists of history.

In 2010, for instance, Mars's opposition happened on January 29th, and even that was a poor one, with Mars appearing just 14 arcseconds wide. In August this year Mars appears about as small as it gets, as it sinks low in twilight on the far side of the Sun from Earth.

Every year I give members of the news media, when they phone Sky & Telescope, the following quote:

"The Mars chain letter is not a bad thing, it's a good thing. It is basically harmless, so it is an immunization. That is, if you make a fool of yourself to your family and friends by sending it to them, you may be embarrassed enough that you won't send them the next e-mail chain letter you get, which could be a lot less benign."

P. S.: The first place to check for facts about any internet rumor, hoax, or urban legend is www.snopes.com. Bookmark it.



Posted by Alan MacRobert, July 26, 2010
related content: Astronomy and society
links: + digg | + del.icio.us | + reddit | + permalink | + rss

comments (39)

Post a Comment


The following comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sky Publishing.
By posting a comment, you agree to our Rules of Conduct and Terms of Use.

First comments (from 39)

talking point

Posted by Stephen July 26, 2007 At 08:47 AM PDT
When the letter arrives from someone known, it's a conversation starter. Be prepared with the next opposition, it's size and brightness, how to spot it in the sky, and offer to see it in a scope. My club has offered Mars opposition open house nights since 2003. Put out a scope for trick or treaters on Halloween. My porch faces west, where Jupiter will be. Mars rises later, when the kids have gone to bed.


2018

Posted by Tunç Tezel July 26, 2007 At 12:19 PM PDT
Just wait for the 2018 opposition of Mars when it will be nearly as close. Then the undead chain letter resurrecting for 15th time will have a meaning again. And people will be able to view Mars with the total Lunar eclipse of 27th July 2018 and see their comperative sizes for themselves.


What if . . .

Posted by Terry Durbin July 27, 2007 At 10:06 AM PDT
How close would Mars have to get to actually be the same apparent diameter as the Moon (roughly I think its about 700,000 miles) and what would the gravitational effects be on the Moon and Earth?


What if. . .

Posted by Alan MacRobert July 27, 2007 At 11:45 AM PDT
> How close would Mars have to get to > actually be the same apparent diameter > as the Moon... Interesting question. Mars is about twice the diameter of the Moon, so it would have to be about twice as far away (that is, about 480,000 miles). Gravity drops off as the square of distance, so from twice as far away a given gram of matter has 1/4 the gravitational pull. But the mass of an object scales as the cube of its diameter (assuming no change in density), so Mars has roughly 8 times the Moon's mass. Therefore, if Mars were close enough to appear the same size in the sky as the Moon does, it would have twice the pull on us. Such a massive object coming so close to the Earth-Moon system would alter it pretty severely, depending on the circumstances of the encounter (how fast or slowly Mars passed by, and in what direction). The most familiar effect of the Moon's gravity is the tides. Tidal effects drop off with the cube of distance, not the square. So the big Mars in the sky, twice as far away as the Moon but with 8 times the mass, would have a tidal effect equal to the Moon's. Alan MacRobert


Mars and the moon

Posted by Justin Skywatcher July 27, 2007 At 12:33 PM PDT
Because of my name and because I am interested in astronomy, I get about 20 of these per year. I try to explain the facts to those people. Interestingly, a few insist that I must be wrong because the email must be right! After all if it were not true, "They" would not say it, would they?


And, is that picture even Mars?

Posted by Kurt July 27, 2007 At 12:55 PM PDT
Plus, as I recall, the image in that email isn't even of Mars, instead it's a satellite of Jupiter or Saturn. At least it's red. If I'm wrong, feel free to correct me.


Mars E-mail

Posted by Doug July 27, 2007 At 07:43 PM PDT
Hey, my e-mail address begins with "moonwatcher" and I have yet to recieve this 'Mars e-mail'. Lucky me!


Mars Hoax

Posted by Silvia Kowollik July 28, 2007 At 09:53 AM PDT
The Picture shows Mars - the long dark structure is Vallis Marineris, the "Grand Cayon" of Mars... During the 2003 and 2005 aperetition I could see this region clear throug a telescope look to my webcam pictures captured with an 6" Newtonian: http://www.sternwarte-zollern-alb.de/mitarbeiterseiten/kowollik/mars/mars2005/index.htm Silvia


Picture of Mars...

Posted by Ryan July 28, 2007 At 09:56 AM PDT
Ah yes you're right that does not appear to be mars in the picture.


Mars hoax is a pain

Posted by gary gragg August 1, 2007 At 01:51 PM PDT
I really enjoyed looking at mars in aug. 2003, but for four years now all my friends and family send loads of e-mails to to me, as soon as they get the hoax e-mail. At first I got a lot of laughts. It was almost as funny as someone saying meade makes a great product. Now it's like everyone forgets the previous year and I send out dozens of replys with the facts. The worst part is when they say "oh I only though you would be intrested. I'm not going to get up at 3:30 am to see it anyway" ARGGGGGG!


Search:
 
Tag:
 
Author:
 
Date:  
 









Sky Publishing, a New Track Media Company
Copyright © 2010 New Track Media. All rights reserved.
Sky & Telescope, Night Sky, and SkyandTelescope.com are registered trademarks of New Track Media