Polarized Light: From Blue Sky to Egg Nebula

Bees see polarized light and use it to navigate to honey. Learn how you can use it to crack the Egg Nebula.

Two Forces Join Forces

When it gets right down to it, light is very strange. Considered as a wave, it's made of oscillating electrical and magnetic fields at right angles to one another moving through space together. The fields don't produce light — they are light!
Emmanuel Boutet / CC BY-SA 3.0

Polarizing. Now there's a word. You might hear it in the context of current politics, but we'll stick to its neutral side as in polarized light. No mudslinging here.

Most of us are familiar with polarization by way of polarized sunglasses, which greatly reduce glare from water, highways, and the sky. How do they work?

Let's start with raw light, which is made of oscillating electric and magnetic waves at right angles to each another moving through space at the speed of light. If you attach one end of a rope to a chair and shake the other end in rhythm, you'll create a lovely rippling wave along its length resembling the oscillating electric field of a light wave. Now imagine that at the same time, you could wiggle the rope perpendicular to the first direction. Then you'd have an alternating series of waves propagating down the rope in synchrony with the first set. Sometimes they're referred to as vibrations. A rope can't do this, but it's no problem for light.

Good Fences Make Good Glare Killers

Unpolarized light has multiple rays with electric fields (magnetic fields ignored for simplicity) arranged at every angle around the beams' central axes. After passing through a polarizer, light vibrating mostly in just one direction passes through.
Kaidor / CC BY-3.0 with annotations by the author

Light from the Sun, a candle flame, or a flashlight is made of an assortment of light rays oscillating in many directions around their central axes like a handful of different ropes, each with their wave crests set off at a multitude of angles from one another. We call this light unpolarized. But a funny thing happens on a sunny day. Air molecules centered 90° from the Sun interact with this confused mess of electromagnetic radiation and scatter back to our eyes mostly rays that oscillate in just one direction called polarized light.

We see the result as a washed-out sky. To reduce glare and increase contrast in photos, photographers sometimes use a polarizer or polarizing filter. A polarizer is a piece of glass or plastic coated with long, parallel chains of molecules that resemble a picket fence. You can pick one up at any camera store or online at Amazon.

Contrast Through Polarization

Using a polarizing filter with an iPhone dramatically darkens the sky some 90° from the Sun (far off to my left). Photographers use the polarizers to increase contrast and create striking land- and skyscape imagery.
Bob King

If you pivot 90° away from the Sun and rotate the filter in front of your eye, the sky in that direction will darken dramatically because the polarized light, which vibrates in just one direction, can't pass through the molecular "slats". If you continue turning the filter, eventually the gaps in the fence will align with the incoming polarizing light and the sky will lighten back up.

Unpolarized In, Polarized Out

When non-polarized light, such as that from the Sun, reflects off a non-metallic surface like a road or lake, at least some of the light leaves polarized in the direction parallel to the surface. Click to view an excellent video primer on polarization.
Bob King

Although you can see where skylight is polarized any time of day, the best time is in the early morning, when the Sun is low in the eastern sky, and again in the evening, when it drops into the west. Using a filter, polarization shows as a broad, dark band centered along the north-south meridian and passing through the zenith.

When unpolarized sunlight strikes a lake or an asphalt road (see above), much of it becomes polarized in the same plane as the surface that it hit. Once again, glare is produced. To eliminate it, polarized sunglasses are coated with horizontally-oriented chains of molecules that block and absorb the offending "horizontally-vibrating" light.

New Planetary Nebula in the Making

The Egg Nebula is a rapidly evolving pre-planetary nebula about 3,000 light-years away from us. Spanning about one light-year, it gets its name from early photos which show a bright, fuzzy, oval-shaped nebula. Thick dust blocks the center star from view, while episodic eruptions created the onion-like dust shells that reflect light from the obscured star. Light vibrating in the plane defined by each dust grain, the central star, and the observer is preferentially reflected, causing some 50% of the nebula's light to be polarized. Three different polarizing filters were used to make this image.
NASA / ESA

Bees, birds, fish, bats, and other animals can sense polarized light and use it for orientation and navigation, proving that sooner or later life finds ways to bend each and every principle of physics towards survival. Astronomers are no different. They exploit polarized light to study, among other things, reflection nebulae. Starlight reflecting from minute particles of dust surrounding stars can become polarized. Carefully scrutiny of the light can tell us the makeup of those dust clouds as well as help us determine a star's location within obscuring nebulosity.

Find the Egg With Ease

This map shows stars down to magnitude +8.8 and will help you find the nebula, located about 3.5° northeast of Epsilon (ε) Cygni, a magnitude +2.5 star at end of the eastern arm of the Northern Cross. The neighborhood also features the Veil Nebula and the bright red dwarf duo, 61 Cygni.
Map: Bob King; Source: Stellarium

I'm aware of just one nebula that's that emits enough polarized light to be obvious in an amateur telescope: the Egg Nebula, also known as PK 80–6.1. It's currently well-placed for evening viewing in Cygnus, not far from the Veil Nebula near Epsilon (ε) Cygni. Several sources list it as magnitude +14, but that's clearly in error. It's much closer to +12 and quite easy to see at a magnification of 64× in my 15-inch reflector with an obvious bipolar shape.

Egg In Your Face

Use this map in conjunction with the wider view map to pinpoint the Egg Nebula. The quadrilateral figure is marked on both maps.
Map: Bob King; Source: Stellarium

Since the Egg measures only 30″ × 15″, it's best at 200× and up, where two fuzzy blobs separated by a narrow dark gap become obvious. The northern blob is clearly brighter with a much brighter, fuzzy central condensation. Within the slice of darkness betwixt the two hides a star that's evolving right before our eyes from red giant to white dwarf as it builds itself a planetary nebula nest.

Using a common linear polarizing filter like the ones sold at telescope shops or camera stores, I placed it between eye and eyepiece and slowly rotated it to see what would happen. The effect was subtle but clear — the brighter lobe changed little, but its partner faded and returned to normal as I turned the filter in a circle. How totally cool to see polarization at work 3,000 light-years from home!

Going, Going, Gone

Martin Schoenball made sketches of the Egg Nebula with the polarizer in different positions.
Martin Schoenball

Amateur astronomer Martin Schoenball used a 10-inch scope to make an even more remarkable observation:

"If you hold the filter between the eyepiece and the eye and rotate it, you can see the nebula fading and brightening. If you rotate the filter so that the nebula is damped, most the nebula vanishes nearly completely. If you rotate the filter again by 90°, the nebula is nearly as bright as without a filter! This is astrophysics live!"

And that astrophysics has told astronomers exactly where within that dark disk the aging star churns, as well as the composition of those gorgeous dust shells: mostly carbon. Carbon created in the deep within the star's core and now ejected into space ready to be swept up someday to make new stars and planets. Living things, too?

For a fun, interactive sketch of the Egg made through an 8-inch telescope with and without a polarizer, visit Jeremy Perez's The Belt of Venus. Now it's time for you to crack the Egg. Let us know how you do.

CATEGORIES
Deep Sky, Explore the Night with Bob King, Observing
RELATED POSTS
Bob King

About Bob King

Amateur astronomer since childhood and long-time member of the American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO), Bob King also teaches community education astronomy and writes the blog Astro Bob. The universe invites us on an adventure every single night. All we need do is look up. Check out my forthcoming book "Night Sky with the Naked Eye" (on Amazon and BN) about all the great things you can see at night without any special equipment.

8 thoughts on “Polarized Light: From Blue Sky to Egg Nebula

  1. Antonio Mario

    Hi Bob, thanks for the interesting article!

    A quick comment on your remark about polarized sunglasses having vertically-oriented molecules (to cut reflections from asphalt). Actually, those molecules are horizontally-oriented (!). Electrons will then be also more free to move horizontally and hence absorb more that polarization. Vertical polarization will then pass through more easily.

    I’ve been meaning to give it a shot at the Egg Nebula for quite some time now. Quite a bit North (some 60deg when on the meridian for me) but I’ll try.

    Thanks.

    1. Bob KingBob King Post author

      Thank you Antonio – you are correct! Thank you for noticing the slip. Now corrected. You’ll enjoy the Egg Nebula – I hope you have the opportunity to see it.

  2. SNH

    Hey,
    I have two polarizing filters each with a 30% transmission that I use for when looking at the moon. Will those by chance work on your deliciously exciting object!?!

  3. Walter ClaytonWalter Clayton

    I took a look at this with my 10in using an 8.8mm 2in Meade eyepiece. we were at our dark sky site near Ludowici, Ga which is pretty dark, but, not, like out in the desert dark. It was VERY humid though. We had some clouds move through during the evening, but, we did get some nice viewing in.

    I did see the nebula. I put my polarized filer in and found that if I turned the eyepiece, the nebula did change. What I found interesting was that as I turned, the nebula faded but became more of a point source.

    WAC

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

COMMENT