Beyond the Printed Page: Messier 17

No matter what you call it, Messier 17 is one deep-sky object to which you'll find yourself returning throughout your observing life.

Messier 17 Sketch Howard Banich

Howard Banich drew this sketch of M17 on August 15, 1974, using his homemade 8 inch f/4 Newtonian. The multi-named H II region definitely looks like the Checkmark Nebula in this view.
Howard Banich

In our September 2017 issue, Contributing Editor Howard Banich examined the science and history of Messier 17, an H II region in Sagittarius also known as the Swan Nebula, Omega Nebula, Checkmark Nebula, Horseshoe Nebula, and Lobster Nebula.

The Messier objects are often treated as quick and easy targets, names you can quickly check off your observing list before moving onto the next title. But Banich has proven that you can get a lifetime of observing even out of such well-known objects. He's been observing and sketching M17 since 1974! As he reports:

"My first sketches of M17 were made from a suburb of Denver, Colorado. The sky was pretty dark back then — the summer Milky Way was easily visible on clear, moonless nights — so observing from home was actually quite good. I was using my homemade 8-inch f/4 Newtonian on a German equatorial mount, and was just starting to figure out how to draw at the eyepiece.

"Although I didn’t record the magnifications used to make the drawing, I had a 20-mm Erfle eyepiece that gave 41× and a 12.5-mm Orthoscopic that produced 69×, and I probably used both eyepieces while making this sketch.

"As mentioned in the August 2017 issue of S&T, the shape of M17 through the 8-inch looked like a checkmark, and my 1974 sketch shows no sign of the curved extension that gave rise to the Omega, Horseshoe, Swan, and Lobster names for the nebula. In that sense, its apparent shape had more in common with the near-infrared image of M17, minus the rich NGC 6618 star cluster, than it does with the sketch I made in August 2016 with my 28-inch scope. Aperture — and wavelength — make a big difference."

As Banich's multiple sketches demonstrate, returning to an object at different times, with different telescopes and eyepieces, can reveal parts of an object we'd overlooked — or just weren't able to see — on earlier visits.

Further Reading

Patrick S. Broos et al. "The Young Stellar Population in M17 Revealed by Chandra." Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 169 (April 2007): 353-385.

Edward S. Holden. "The Horsehoe Nebula in Sagittarius." Popular Science Monthly 8 (January 1876): 269-281.

Matthew S. Povich et al."The Extended Environment of M17: A Star Formation History." Astrophysical Journal 696 (May 10, 2009): 1278-1306.

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.