Mind the Gap: Gaia Mission Reveals the Insides of Stars

Using "Big Data" collected by the Gaia satellite and released earlier this year, astronomers have discovered a hiccup in stellar luminosities that may point to a new understanding of stellar structure.

Gaia's Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram

The Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, constructed from Gaia data on more than 4 million stars within 5,000 light-years, plots stars' colors against their luminosities. A star lives the prime of its life in the main sequence (labeled). Lower-mass stars end their lives as white dwarfs, while more massive stars evolve as giants before going supernova. 
Gaia DPAC / Carine Babusiaux (Grenoble Institute of Planetology and Astrophysics, Observatory of Paris)

If you’ve ever taken Astronomy 101, you might remember the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram (or you might still have it tattooed on your arm). The HR diagram, as it’s commonly known, is basically a one-stop stellar shop: Based on a star’s color and brightness, the diagram reveals its size and temperature, what stage of evolution it’s in, its internal structure, and much more. First put down on paper in the 1900s, this simple diagram is still revealing stellar secrets more than a century later.

After the release of the Gaia satellite’s second dataset, with high-precision distance measurements to an astonishing 1.7 billion stars, astronomers in the Gaia collaboration immediately put together multiple versions of the HR diagram. The sheer mass of stars paints a vivid, “Big Data” picture of stellar evolution. Stars spend most of their lives fusing hydrogen into helium in the so-called main sequence before aging onto the red giant branches, where more massive stars eventually go boom, or the white dwarf sequence, where less massive stars gradually fade away into obscurity.

Now, a team of astronomers led by Wei-Chun Jao (Georgia State University) has announced the discovery of a narrow but distinctive gap in the diagram in the July 1st Astrophysical Journal Letters (free preprint available here). The gap is so distinct that it might look like an instrumental artifact, but Jao and colleagues see the same gap in stars with infrared data from 2MASS, so it's definitely real. While most of the main sequence transitions smoothly from one type of star to the next, there’s a tiny hiccup in the transition among the coolest, faintest red dwarfs. Known as M stars, these are the smallest, lowest-luminosity stars in the hydrogen-fusing main sequence (the “Me”s from Oh Be a Fine Guy/Gal Kiss Me).

Mind the Stellar Gap

This plot zooms in on the HR diagram created with Gaia data (where MG represents a star's luminosity and MBP–MRP represents a star's color). The gap occurs at a narrow range of luminosities that correspond to red dwarf stars with roughly a third the Sun's mass.
Jao et al. The Astrophysical Journal, 1 July 2018

The very smallest M stars are unique in that they have a fully convective interior, meaning their whole insides are a boiling mass of plasma. The very largest M stars are more like the Sun, where a convective envelope surrounds a radiative zone, a denser area where boiling motions are suppressed. Energy travels more slowly in this compressed interior — it can take anywhere from a few thousand to a few million years for a photon to escape from inside the Sun.

Fully convective star vs. convective star with radiative core

Low-mass M dwarfs are fully convective, which means boiling motions mix up the insides of the star. Above a certain mass, though, the core attains a high enough pressure that boiling motions are no longer possible and photons are instead transmitted more slowly in a radiative zone. Fusions reactions occur more efficiently in cores that can better mix their fusion products.
Wikimedia Commons

The transition between these two interior structures occurs when red dwarf stars have about a third of the Sun’s mass. The gap that Jao and colleagues found is at exactly that mass. The question is, why? After all, most theoretical models of stellar structure show a smooth transition here — in other words, there ought to be just as many stars with a fully convective structure and 0.34 solar masses as there are stars with a radiative core and 0.35 solar masses.

Shortly after Jao’s study was published in the July 1st Astrophysical Journal, another paper led by James MacDonald and John Gizis (both at University of Delaware) appeared on the astronomy preprint archive. The gap, these authors argue, is actually a feature of existing theory. It’s just that finding it requires examining a very narrow mass range. Gaia showed them where to look.

The gap, they explain, comes about because interior structure affects the efficiency of the stars’ power source. The boiling motions in the cores of smaller, lower-mass stars help mix intermediate products of fusion reactions, allowing the star to fuse hydrogen more efficiently and steadily increase its luminosity. More massive red dwarfs are less efficient fusion reactors and stay relatively constant in luminosity. As one structure replaces the other, the difference creates a dearth of stars of a particular brightness.

Still, questions remain. The incredible detail in Gaia data shows that a very few stars do appear in the gap — why are they there? Also, the gap appears to be wider for stars less polluted by heavier elements — what is it about these “purer” stars that affects their stellar structure? A century after astronomers first began understanding stars in a systematic way, stars continue to prove themselves more complicated than we knew.

3 thoughts on “Mind the Gap: Gaia Mission Reveals the Insides of Stars

  1. Lou

    Interestingly, a press release from Georgia State University says: “it appears the gap is caused by a slight shrinking in size if a star is convective all the way through.” Could it be both shrinking and mixing at play?

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.