State Your Purpose

1 percent of ACS view
Does all this have a purpose?
One of the many magazines we receive at the office is American Scientist. I like going through it because it has interesting articles, sometimes about nerdy subjects that I otherwise wouldn't have considered. A recent issue had an article analyzing the (mis)spellings of Viagra e-mail spam. Plus, the magazine has sciency cartoons.

In flipping through the September-October issue earlier in the week, I found an intriguing advertisement from the John Templeton Foundation. The two-page ad asks the question: "Does the Universe have a Purpose?" and includes the responses from seven scientists, including several astronomers. Interesting reading! The ad has just parts of their responses; the full essays — and the responses from four additional people — went online today at

My view? I on board with Lawrence Krauss. I don't think the universe necessarily has a purpose. It could, but I'm content that it does not. Stuff happens — there doesn't need to be a meaning behind it. Billions of years is a long time to have matter and energy simmer.

2 thoughts on “State Your Purpose

  1. Chris Z

    I hadn’t looked at American Scientist before and found it to be a very interesting site.

    Although the question of purpose is interesting, it is one of those questions that we can’t currently answer. It can be fun to think about and discuss.

    I actually found the article “Modern Cosmology: Science or Folktale?” by Michael J. Disney to be very good. I think we all know that the study of cosmology is handicapped by the very limited amount of data available, but this article expresses this in a concise and understandable way.

  2. Jeff

    I rarely agree with your politics, but on this subject, I am with you. The universe needs no purpose. *WE* need it to have a purpose because *WE* like to believe *WE* are significant. Without a purpose, *WE* have no purpose. Or so *WE* want to believe. Notice the ego-centric view point.

    So I am okay with everyone else saying there must be a purpose or this is all for naught. Even though you and I know, there is no purpose needed. *WE* just ‘are’. And that should be good enough? Oui?


All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.