An Ancient Eclipse in Ithaca

The iconic statue of Odysseus at Ithaca harbor. Perhaps one can imagine how it looked 3000 years ago.
Michael Knowles

During my May 2017 trip to Kefalonia I had the chance to visit the neighboring island of Ithaca.

Because of my interest in astronomy and general knowledge of the epic Trojan War story of Odysseus, I was intrigued to discover that an eclipse coincided with Odysseus’ return to Ithaca, his homeland, following his involvement in the legendary 10-year Trojan War and his further 10-year struggle home. Homer scribed accounts of Odysseus using star constellation pointers as an aid to navigate his challenging sail back home after the Trojan War. The Odyssey is the first ever account of its kind of a human interaction 3000 years ago using astronomy as an aid in sea navigation by the stars. See sky map below.

Odysseus’ epic, originally part of Ancient Greece’s oral tradition, was put into written form between 750 and 650 B.C. It is one of the oldest surviving works of Ancient Greek literature. Over the millennia, it has undergone several delicate restoration processes, enabling modern day researchers to study the text.

The night sky visible in the time of Odysseus.

NASA collaborating with archaeometry researchers has deciphered Homer's legendary Odyssey using the scripted poems to interpret the meanings non just in an ancient mythological setting, but also in a modern astronomical context. Their efforts have narrowed down that the eclipse mentioned in the Odyssey was an autumn annular eclipse that occurred on October 30, 1207 B.C.

A scene from the end of the Trojan War.
Tetraktyas

Homer, using lunar and solar calendars and his knowledge of the motions of celestial objects, predicted eclipses. The timing of a New Moon event is also included in the Odyssey, adding credence to the idea that Odysseus's vengeful act — slaying his wife Penelope's suitors — occurred during the darkening phases of the eclipse.

This ancient eclipse research has also established that the epic Trojan War commenced in 1227 B.C. and culminated in 1217 B.C.

For the reader’s further exploration, books 20 to 22 of the Odyssey contain references to the eclipse.

The author preparing to photograph the August 21, 2017 eclipse at Menan Buttes.
Michael Knowles

I have been very lucky and chased to date seven total solar eclipses round the world — most recently, I experienced the USA total solar eclipse at Menan Buttes near Idaho Falls on August 21, 2017, bringing with me a further perspective in an ancient reflective way.

Menan Buttes, a National Natural Landmark, are comprised of the North and South Menan Buttes — two of the world's largest dormant volcanic tuff cones, which stand at an elevation of 5,619 feet.

This was a magnificent area where the panoramic landscape encompassed viewers. My priority was to find a sparsely populated location. As this hostile environment is home to many species of wildlife, including the Western rattlesnake, care had to be taken when selecting a viewing spot.

As the Sun's rays succumbed to the transiting Moon, it was if we were being transcended into a different universe. Everyone viewing was absorbed in the astronomical spectacle. Then, at the moment of totality, euphoria gripped us all.

I think it is apt to say we can be sure in the time of Odysseus, civilizations would also be in awe of an eclipse.

3 thoughts on “An Ancient Eclipse in Ithaca

  1. Anthony BarreiroAnthony Barreiro

    When they say the eclipse happened on October 30, 1207 BCE, is that a Gregorian calendar date? In which case, it’s anachronistic by 2800 years. I wonder what date Odysseus would have written on his calendar, if he had been literate and had a day planner.

  2. Michael KnowlesMichael Knowles

    Hi Anthony,
    As far as I know after delving into your query the Gregorian dating mechanism introduced in 1582 has been taken into account. Researchers involved both in ancient disciplines and modern day researchers Nasa have refined as much as possible to date, to establish the Ithaca Odysseus solar eclipse and time frame.

  3. Milton LachmanMilton Lachman

    The date is on the ‘proleptic’ Julian calendar, standard in academia for pre-Catholic-Era dates except in astronomy for which such years are less by 1 (due to a ‘year zero’) as at NASA’s webpage for this eclipse: https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/SEsearch/SEsearchmap.php?Ecl=-12061030
    But note that it didn’t pass over Ithaca, but over N. Africa (e.g. Canopus, where Menelaus made landfall). This slip-up ironically typifies archaeo-astronomy’s annointed Aryans as a mote in their own eyes when pointing out the beam in Velikovsky’s; as explained by the Messiah when saying in Matthew 10.36 (BBE) that ‘a man will be hated by those of his house’ – Judah in His case, and academia in Velikovsky’s. Had his publishing house been that of L. Ron Hubbard, he’d have been likewise ignored, and wouldn’t have been ridiculed in Beatty’s article in the March 2018 issue as if he had ‘declared’ in Hubbard-like fashion his rerendering of the mythological record as fact. The Greeks’ declaring one of the goddesses who instigated the Trojan War to have sprung from the head of Zeus may well have been their Scientological rendering of Jupiter subjecting ‘Venus’ to the slingshot-effect in reverse, so as to ‘spawn’ a new planet. It must have appeared to those as ignorant of orbital mechanics as Velikovsky as if Jupiter was ejecting ‘Venus’ rather than diverting a large sulfureous comet (let’s call it Minerva). Had both sides of the debate not have had their vision impaired, it might have occurred to them that Minerva’s collision with Venus was later wrought by Homer into an etiology for the War.

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

COMMENT

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.