What size first telescope mirror should I make?

What size is best for someone’s first attempt at making a telescope mirror?

koolish_stellafane_mirror_making

Mirror-making at stellafane.
Richard Koolish

Most books on telescope making recommend starting with either a 6- or an 8-inch mirror, and that’s good advice. Either size is suitable for a first-timer, but a 6-inch will probably take a little less time to complete.

What is perhaps an equally important consideration is the mirror’s focal ratio (focal length divided by diameter). In general, long-focus mirrors (f/8 or greater) are easier to make but harder to test, whereas short-focus mirrors (f/5 or less) are harder to make but easier to test. For this reason I usually recommend f/6, which provides an excellent balance between the demands of testing and fabricating.

But what if you really want a big mirror? Most experienced glass pushers say that it will take you less total time to make a 6-or 8-inch first and then a big one, as opposed to starting right off with a big mirror. The basics of mirror making are pretty much the same regardless of size; only the amount of time required for each step changes. But the advantage of a smaller mirror is that you can more quickly undo a mistake and get back on track than you can with a big mirror — and with a first mirror, you can count on making plenty of mistakes!

— Gary Seronik

All comments must follow the Sky & Telescope Terms of Use and will be moderated prior to posting. Please be civil in your comments. Sky & Telescope reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter’s username, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

COMMENT